The Life of Froude by Herbert W. (Herbert Woodfield) Paul
Author:Herbert W. (Herbert Woodfield) Paul [Paul, Herbert W.]
Language: eng
Format: epub
ISBN: 9781722383411
Google: _Yc1AQAAIAAJ
Goodreads: 40761427
Publisher: CreateSpace Independent Publishing Platform
Published: 2018-07-07T00:00:00+00:00
Several years afterwards, in 1878, the subject was fully discussed, and Froude's conclusions were shown to be unsound, by another historian, William Edward Hartpole Lecky. Lecky was a much more formidable critic than Freeman. Calm in temperament and moderate in language, he could take part in an historical controversy without getting into a rage. Freeman, after pages of mere abuse, would pounce with triumphant ejaculations upon a misprint. Lecky did not waste his time either on scolding or on trifles. The faults he found were grave, and his censure was not the less severe for being decorous. An Anglicised Irishman, living in England, though a graduate of Dublin University, Lecky became known when he was a very young man for a brilliant little book on Leaders of Irish Opinion. He had since published mature and valuable histories of rationalism, and of morals. His History of England in the Eighteenth Century is likely to remain a standard book, being written with fairness, lucidity, and candour. It is true that in his Irish chapters, with which alone I am concerned, Lecky, like Froude, wrote with a purpose. He was an Irish patriot, and bent on making out the best possible case for his own country.
At the same time he was, for an Irishman, singularly impartial between Catholic and Protestant, leaning, if at all, to the Protestant side. Yet he repudiated with indignant vehemence Froude's attempt to connect the Catholic Church with these atrocious crimes. I am bound to say that I think he disproves the charge of ecclesiastical complicity. The evidence upon which Froude relied, the only evidence accessible, is the collection of presentments by Grand Juries, with the accompanying depositions, in Dublin Castle. In the first sixty years of the eighteenth century there were twenty-eight cases of abduction thus recorded. In only four of them can it be shown that the perpetrator was a Catholic and the victim a Protestant. In only one, which Froude has described at much length, did the criminal try to make a Protestant girl attend mass. For one of the cases, which according to Froude went unpunished, two men were hanged. "The truth is," says Lecky, "that the crime was merely the natural product of a state of great lawlessness and barbarism."* These offences have so completely disappeared from Ireland that even the memory of them has perished, and yet Ireland remains as Catholic as ever. Arthur Young, who denounces them as scandalous to a civilised community, does not hint that they had anything to do with religion, nor were they ever cited in defence of the penal code. Froude was led astray by religious prejudice, and forgot for once the historian in the advocate. The penal codes were rather the cause than the effect of crime and outrage in Ireland. By setting authority on one side, and popular religion on the other, they made a breach of the law a pious and meritorious act. The bane of English rule in Ireland at that time was
Download
This site does not store any files on its server. We only index and link to content provided by other sites. Please contact the content providers to delete copyright contents if any and email us, we'll remove relevant links or contents immediately.
Room 212 by Kate Stewart(4716)
The Crown by Robert Lacey(4555)
Endurance: Shackleton's Incredible Voyage by Alfred Lansing(4474)
The Iron Duke by The Iron Duke(4098)
The Rape of Nanking by Iris Chang(4003)
Killing England by Bill O'Reilly(3889)
Joan of Arc by Mary Gordon(3766)
Say Nothing by Patrick Radden Keefe(3696)
I'll Give You the Sun by Jandy Nelson(3248)
Shadow of Night by Deborah Harkness(3160)
Hitler's Monsters by Eric Kurlander(3142)
Blood and Sand by Alex Von Tunzelmann(3040)
Mary, Queen of Scots, and the Murder of Lord Darnley by Alison Weir(3033)
Darkest Hour by Anthony McCarten(3007)
Margaret Thatcher: The Autobiography by Thatcher Margaret(2962)
Eleanor & Park by Rainbow Rowell(2926)
Red Famine: Stalin's War on Ukraine by Anne Applebaum(2804)
Book of Life by Deborah Harkness(2704)
The One Memory of Flora Banks by Emily Barr(2673)
